Journal · September 2026

Learning by ear versus reading music.

The Native American flute is traditionally played by ear. Nakai tablature exists for those who want notation. Here's when each helps — and what beginners should do first.

← All journal entries
Christina Tijerina

One of the small surprises for many new Native American flute players is that there's an entire conversation in the community about whether to learn by ear or learn to read notation. The instrument has a long tradition of being played without written music. It also has a respected modern tablature system. Both approaches are legitimate. Which to choose depends on what you want to do with the instrument — and the order matters more than the choice.

The traditional approach: by ear

Across most of the Indigenous traditions in which the Native American flute has been played, the music was carried by listening. Songs passed from elder to student. Personal songs were composed in the moment, often outdoors, often alone, with no expectation that they would ever be written down. The instrument's whole architecture — the pentatonic scale that contains no wrong notes, the breath-driven phrasing that follows the player's body — fits a music made of listening rather than reading.

The Flutopedia introduction to tablature itself recommends that, "if you've just begun with Native American flutes, it's advisable to avoid tablature until you are comfortable with your instrument and can improvise your own melodies." That recommendation comes from a tablature-friendly source. It tells you something important about the culture of the instrument.

The modern alternative: Nakai tablature

In the late twentieth century, R. Carlos Nakai — who appears prominently in my listening list of famous Native American flute players — developed a tablature system specifically for the Native American flute. Nakai Tablature uses a five-line staff in which each notation position represents a specific fingering on the flute, not an absolute pitch. The same Nakai tablature can be played on any Native American flute regardless of key — the system tells you which fingers to lift, not what frequency to produce. This is a real innovation. It made it possible to teach the instrument across distance and to capture original compositions in a stable form.

Interval tablature — a different system also widely used — captures the relationship between notes rather than absolute fingerings. Flute Craft's introduction covers how both systems work.

These notation systems are useful. They let you learn songs that have been written down by others. They let you preserve your own compositions. They let you communicate with other players across distance. None of that was practical before notation existed for this instrument.

The case for starting by ear

Even with good notation available, my strong recommendation for any first-year player is to stay off the page. Here's why:

When tablature genuinely helps

After about a year of by-ear play, tablature becomes useful for several specific purposes:

The honest hybrid

Most experienced Native American flute players I know use a hybrid approach. They learned by ear, they can read tablature, they primarily improvise, they occasionally write down compositions, and they think of notation as a memory aid rather than a primary mode of playing. That's roughly my own practice. I read tablature when learning a specific traditional song. I rarely read while performing. I use my ear and my breath, and the notation lives in the background as a reference.

My teaching approach reflects this. New students don't see tablature for at least the first three months. The first year focuses on listening, breath, fingering, and improvisation. Tablature comes in eventually as a tool, never as a starting point. The order is the practice, and the practice is what creates the player. More on the lessons themselves on the lessons page.

For the broader picture of how to think about learning this instrument, see The Complete Guide to the Native American Flute. For the specific scale that makes by-ear play possible, see The Pentatonic Scale and Why It Sounds Right.

Sources & further reading

Learn the by-ear way.

Lessons that start with listening, breath, and improvisation. Tablature comes later, as a tool. Online worldwide via Zoom, or in person.

See Lesson Details